The United States Supreme Court has taken up a legal dispute involving Coinbase and its users, specifically addressing an important procedural question about whether a judge or arbitrator should decide which contract governs disputes.
According to a Bloomberg report, this problem arises from conflicting agreements between the parties, with one contract advocating arbitration and another supporting court litigation.
Coinbase had initially applied arbitration clauses to its customers, but a complication arose with a sweepstakes agreement that directed dispute resolution to California courts. Following allegations of false advertising, customers took legal action through a class-action lawsuit, challenging Coinbase’s regular arbitration process.
Coinbase’s efforts to promote arbitration faced opposition in lower courts. A federal judge in California, backed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, said the lottery agreement, which favored the court ruling, should stand. As a result, the company’s request to take the dispute to arbitration was not granted.
Related: Coinbase Cuts Losses as Crypto Trading Volumes Fall in Q3
This judicial reluctance comes despite a recent decision by the Supreme Court, which came down 5 to 4 in favor of Coinbase in a related matter. The court then ruled in favor of the company’s efforts to stay customer lawsuits while it sought to take the disputes to arbitration.
During this legal dispute, Coinbase has remained proactive. The company has expanded its services, introducing new commercial options for its users. Eligible retail customers can now participate in cryptocurrency futures trading, with more affordable contract sizes, representing a fraction of the value of Bitcoin (BTC) and Ether (ETH).
The Supreme Court’s decision to take up this case represents a fundamental development for companies that use arbitration clauses. It also highlights the court’s continued involvement in defining the distinctions between arbitration and legal proceedings. The verdict will likely affect the formulation and enforcement of user agreements, particularly in the ever-evolving arena of digital currency trading.
Magazine: Samsung Bitcoin ETF drops $700 million, Coinbase exits Japan: Asia Express